Repair or Replace? The 50% Rule and How Long Appliances Last

Replace an appliance when the repair would cost more than half the price of a new one, or when it is near the end of its normal life and a major part has failed. In most other cases a repair is the cheaper choice. Below we explain the 50% rule, the cases where it gives the wrong answer, and how long each appliance usually lasts, with typical repair costs in Los Angeles.

The 50% rule in one sentence

Consumer Reports put it simply: don't spend more than 50 percent of the cost of a new product on repairing an old one. The math takes a minute. Find the price of a comparable new model, including delivery and installation, and cut it in half. If the repair quote is below that number, repairing usually makes sense. If it's above, start shopping.

Here is an example. A dishwasher that costs $900 to replace, with installation, has a limit of $450. A $280 pump repair passes easily. A $600 job to replace a leaking tub and a control board does not.

When the 50% rule gives the wrong answer

The rule is a starting point. Consumer Reports itself now uses a more detailed approach that looks at age, purchase price, and depreciation for each type of appliance. In practice, four things change the answer.

Age

A repair at 40% of the replacement price is a good deal on a four-year-old washer. On a washer that's 11 years old, the same repair buys a machine that's already past its average life, and the next part could fail soon after. As a rough guide, the closer an appliance is to the lifespan in the table below, the lower your limit should be. Once it's past that age, a quarter or a third of the replacement price is a safer limit than half.

Built-in and high-end appliances

A built-in Sub-Zero refrigerator, a Miele dishwasher, or a Wolf range costs several times more than a standard model and is built for a longer life. Sub-Zero says its products are designed to last about 20 years on average, and Miele tests several of its appliance lines to simulate 20 years of typical use. Replacing a built-in unit also means matching the cutout, the panels, and sometimes the cabinetry. For these appliances, even an expensive repair is often the better choice.

One repair or a pattern

A single worn part on an otherwise healthy appliance is a normal repair. A third service call in two years is a different story. If the same appliance keeps breaking, add up what you have already spent before you approve the next repair.

Energy and water use

Older refrigerators, freezers, and washers use more power and water than current models. That doesn't change the repair math much on its own, but on a fridge or freezer that is already near the end of its life, it can tip the decision toward replacement.

How long appliances last and when to replace them

The lifespans below come from the National Association of Home Builders (NAHB) study on the life expectancy of home components, which reports average years of use by the first owner. Repair costs are typical ranges in Los Angeles. You get the exact price after our $65 diagnostic, which goes toward the repair.

ApplianceAverage life, yearsTypical repair cost in LAReplace instead when
Refrigerator13 (standard), 9 (compact)$190 to $570A compressor or refrigerant leak on a standard fridge older than about 10 years. Built-in models are usually worth repairing.
Freezer11$200 to $470A compressor failure or refrigerant leak on an older chest or upright freezer.
Dishwasher9$190 to $480A rusted or cracked tub. Also a pump and a control board failing together on a unit over 7 years old.
Washer10$200 to $500Worn tub bearings on an older front-load washer, since the whole drum has to come apart.
Dryer13$160 to $520Rarely. Most dryer parts are inexpensive, so repair is the usual answer even on older units.
Gas range15$210 to $540Rarely. Igniters, valves, and sensors are standard parts. Replace only after repeated failures.
Electric range13$210 to $540A cracked glass cooktop or a failed control board on a budget model.
Oven or cooktopNot listed separately$200 to $530 (oven), $200 to $700 (cooktop)Same logic as a range. Built-in wall ovens and cooktops are usually worth repairing because a new one has to fit the existing cutout.
Microwave9$100 to $380Almost always for countertop models. Over-the-range and built-in units are often worth repairing.
Range hood14$100 to $300A failed motor on a basic under-cabinet hood. Custom and built-in hoods are usually worth repairing.

Other studies give slightly different numbers. Estimates from the Association of Home Appliance Manufacturers (AHAM) put a dishwasher at about 12 years, a front-load washer at about 9, and a top-load washer at about 11. Treat every figure here as an average, not a deadline. How often you use the appliance and how well it's maintained matter more than the year on the label.

Appliance by appliance

Refrigerators and freezers

Most fridge repairs are worth doing at any age: fan motors, defrost heaters, thermostats, door gaskets, ice makers, and control boards. The big decision comes with a sealed system failure, meaning a bad compressor or a refrigerant leak. On a standard fridge older than about 10 years, that repair often comes close to the 50% line. On a built-in model it usually doesn't. See our refrigerator repair and freezer repair pages for common problems.

Dishwashers

Dishwashers have one of the shortest lifespans in the home, so age matters more here. Drain pumps, door latches, inlet valves, and heating elements are routine repairs. A rusted or cracked tub can't really be fixed. And if a budget unit that's 7 or more years old needs both a pump and a control board, that money is usually better spent on a new machine. If yours is holding water, start with our guide to a dishwasher not draining. More on our dishwasher repair and Bosch dishwasher repair pages.

Washers

A washer that won't drain, spin, or start usually has a problem with the pump, lid switch, door lock, or drive belt, and these are reasonable repairs. Failed tub bearings on a front-load washer are the expensive repair, since the whole drum has to come apart. On an older machine, that job often isn't worth it. Details on our washer repair page.

Dryers

Dryers are the easiest call. Belts, rollers, heating elements, igniters, and thermal fuses are inexpensive parts, and most dryers can be repaired well past 10 years. A dryer that keeps overheating or takes forever to dry often has a clogged vent rather than a bad part, so check that first. If the drum turns but the clothes stay cold, read our guide to a dryer not heating. See dryer repair, Samsung dryer repair, and dryer vent cleaning.

Ranges, ovens, and cooktops

Gas ranges are among the longest-lasting appliances in a kitchen. Igniters, valves, bake elements, and temperature sensors are standard parts. The costly repairs are a cracked glass cooktop on an electric range or a failed control board on a budget model, and either one can push a low-priced range past the 50% line. Wall ovens and cooktops use the same kinds of parts, and the NAHB study doesn't list them separately. Read more on oven repair, range repair, and cooktop repair.

Microwaves

A countertop microwave is almost always cheaper to replace than to repair. Over-the-range and built-in microwaves are different: replacing one means matching the mounting and trim, so a repair is often the better choice there. See microwave repair.

A quick check before you decide

Run through these five questions before you approve a big repair or buy something new.

  • How old is it compared with the average life in the table?
  • Is the repair quote more than half the price of a comparable new model, installed?
  • Is this the first major repair or the second or third in the last couple of years?
  • Is it a built-in or high-end model that would be costly to replace and fit?
  • Does anything else about the appliance already bother you, like noise, energy use, or capacity?

If most of your answers point toward replacing, it's probably time. If the appliance is middle-aged and the quote is well under half, repair it.

What a repair visit costs with us

Our diagnostic visit is $65, and that amount is credited toward the repair if you go ahead. The technician finds the cause and gives you a price for parts and labor before any work starts. Repairs come with a 183-day warranty on parts and labor. Typical prices for common repairs are on our appliance repair cost page, and if you call before 11 AM, there's a good chance we can come the same day.

Frequently asked questions

What is the 50% rule for appliances?

Don't spend more than half the price of a new, comparable appliance on repairing the old one. If the repair costs less than that, fixing it is usually the better deal. Lower the limit for appliances that are near the end of their usual life.

How long does a refrigerator last?

A standard refrigerator lasts about 13 years on average, according to the NAHB study. Built-in brands like Sub-Zero are designed to last longer, around 20 years.

Is it worth repairing a 10-year-old appliance?

It depends on the appliance and the repair. A 10-year-old dryer or gas range still has years left, and most repairs are worth it. A 10-year-old dishwasher or washer is at or past its average life, so a major repair is harder to justify.

Is it worth fixing a dishwasher?

For a drain pump, latch, or inlet valve, usually yes. For a leaking tub or several failed parts on an older budget model, a new dishwasher is often the better buy.

Do I pay the $65 diagnostic if I decide to replace the appliance?

Yes, the $65 covers the visit and diagnosis. If you go ahead with the repair, the $65 is credited toward it.

Sources

Not sure your appliance is worth fixing? Call (213) 761-5757 and book a $65 diagnostic. The technician finds the cause and gives you one price for parts and labor, so you can run the 50% rule with real numbers. The $65 is credited toward the repair if you go ahead.